Glitter alternatives and ‘eco’ glitter: Are they truly more sustainable? 

Glitter alternatives and ‘eco’ glitter:
Are they truly more sustainable? 

What glitter alternatives exist and what do they promise?

Especially since the EU microplastics ban came into place, awareness around glitter pollution has grown, while many “biodegradable”, “eco-friendly” and “bioglitters” have been brought to the market as alternatives. These alternatives are said to be more sustainable; instead of being fully made out of plastic or mica, they have the following modifications: 

  • The plastic is usually replaced by a plant-based material such as cellulose. 
  • Often, just like in conventional glitter, the shiny effect comes from aluminium or mica (natural or synthetic – see our previous article, which explains the pros and cons of natural vs synthetic mica). 
  • Colors can be created with cellulose or mica rather than dyes or metal layers.

A group of researchers came up with the following definitions for each type of glitter: 

Source: Zainini et al. (2024)

Some of the first plastic‑free glitters for the public were made from tree‑based cellulose, especially from fast‑growing eucalyptus. This cellulose is turned into a thin film, cut into minuscule shapes, then coloured and sometimes coated with shellac (a resin from the lac beetle) to give it the shiny finish. Most of these products are labeled as ‘biodegradable’ or ‘compostable’.

Other crafters use crushed glass, glass seed beads or glass micro‑beads instead of plastic glitter. The environmental claim here is that glass doesn’t release microplastics or harmful chemicals, lasts a long time, and is often made from recycled materials, so it’s a more durable and lower-pollution option—especially for crafts that won’t end up in waterways.

Are glitter alternatives actually more eco-friendly?

Biodegradable or compostable glitter usually only breaks down properly in composting conditions (especially industrial composting), not in natural water or soil. So, it’s important to check labels that say that is is possible to compost the products at home. In the right conditions, these glitters can break down in about 4–6 weeks into water, carbon dioxide, and organic matter. But if they contain non-biodegradable parts, they may only partly break down and can still release polluting particles.

In the EU, glitter sold as biodegradable does not legally have to carry a sign or have a certification from an independent, third-party certifier. However, since the EU microplastics ban (October 2023), many companies have tried to obtain such a professional certificate. For example, in 2019, the German company Bioglitter was the first glitter producer to receive the TÜV label stating “OK biodegradable WATER”. However, some of the bioglitter products still contain small amounts of plastic or metal, including aluminium. To obtain the TÜV “OK biodegradable WATER” label, products must biodegrade by at least 90% (or fully biodegrade after 56 days of testing), so 100% biodegradation is not required. In addition, the EU microplastics ban restricts intentionally added microplastics if they are equal to or greater than 0,01 % of the weight of the entire product, meaning that a small amount of microplastics is still allowed. So, names or labels like “bioglitter” and “biodegradable” can be somewhat misleading and consumers have to actually read the ingredient lists to see what is in the product they are buying.

Plus, early research shows that some alternatives — like those made from plant-based cellulose or mica — can still harm small water plants such as duckweed and phytoplankton. In one study, cellulose glitter even doubled the number of invasive New Zealand mud snails. Thus, both regular and eco glitters can affect aquatic life, and labels like “eco-friendly” can also be misleading.

On the bright side, another study found no strong negative effects of cassava- or mica-based glitter on certain freshwater microbes. Scientists say it’s still early days for eco-glitter — we need more research to be sure it’s truly safe for the environment.

What are the other limitations of existing alternatives? 

Even though you can buy some of the above-mentioned alternatives, many other glitter substitutes only exist as lab ideas or tests and never reach the shops. For example, back in 2007, scientists used fish scales to make shiny crystals for cosmetics. Other suggested glitters use a cellulose base with a thin metal (usually aluminium) coating and no plastic layer, but even that metal can still harm wildlife, just like in regular glitter.

In terms of quality, often current alternatives, especially those made out of cellulose, maintain many of the properties of traditional glitter like the shimmery effect or durability, but they usually don’t offer the same water stability and are not suitable for water-based applications. Some are softer than plastic glitter, which may be desired if used on the skin, but in other applications, harder glitter may be preferred.  

Ending on a hopeful note

Glitter alternatives and eco-glitter development are still in their early stages. As ecologist Dr. Green from Anglia Ruskin University says, “ecotoxicological research is needed to test for impacts of any new types of glitter so we don’t end up just creating a new problem”. Until then, we can help by skipping glitter when possible or making sure we use biocompatible materials.

SeaSpark

SeaSpark reimagines glitter in a way that is safe for both people and the planet. We develop 100% biodegradable, non-toxic glitter and shimmering materials using seaweed and other renewable ingredients.

Looking to collaborate? Have any creative ideas for us? Let’s start the conversation. Reach out to us via our Contact Form. 

References 

BBC. (2017, 18 November). The eco-friendly guide to glitter. URL: https://www.bbc.com/news/newsbeat-42038411

Bioglitter. (n.d.). Bioglitter® – The right choice for many industries. URL: https://www.sili.eu/en/products/bioglitter/bioglitter-overview/ 

Collins, S. (2021). Sustainable, biodegradable glitter – from your fruit bowl. URL: https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/glitter 

European Commission. (2023). Regulation 2023/2055–Restriction of microplastics intentionally added to products. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/2055/oj

Green, D. S., Jefferson, M., Boots, B., & Stone, L. (2021). All that glitters is litter? Ecological impacts of conventional versus biodegradable glitter in a freshwater habitat. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 402, 124070. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.124070

TÜV. (2013). Program OK 1: Bio products – degradation in water. URL: https://be.tuvaustria.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/73/2024/03/CS-OK11-EN_OK_biodegradable_WATER.pdf 

White, E. (n.d.). Alternatives to glitter – the solution for sparkle without the plastic. URL: https://www.l-i.co.uk/knowledge-centre/alternatives-to-glitter-the-solution-for-sparkle-without-the-plastic/ 

Worthington, L. (2024, July 19). How do you solve a problem like glitter? National Geographic. URL: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/glitter-microplastics-biodegradable

Zanini, M. L. D. O., Fonseca, L. M., Piecha, C. R., Corrêa, C. D. P. L., Dode, L. B., Zavareze, E. D. R., & Diaz, P. S. (2024). A review of conventional and environmentally sustainable glitter. Environmental Quality Management, 34(2), e22322. https://doi.org/10.1002/tqem.22322

Similar Posts